Review - Robot of Sherwood

Our new Doctor really beings to hit his straps as he takes Clara to meet a legend in Robot of Sherwood.

Season 8, Episode 3 - Robot of Sherwood

This episode gets us back to basics, with The Doctor and Clara resolving to simply do a bit of adventuring in time and space. Clara chooses to go and meet Robin Hood, and despite The Doctor's claims that he is nothing but a myth, meet him they do. After a brief duel and a mild In-Who-Endo (seriously, I don't think they can help themselves), Robin takes The Doctor and Clara to meet his Merry Men.

What follows is a very condensed retelling of the Robin Hood story as we are introduced to the main villain, the Sheriff of Nottingham, who is swiftly shown to be a nasty piece of work. Then we bounce straight to the archery contest for the golden arrow. Things take a sharp turn away from the norm here, as The Sheriff's knights turn out to be robots, and The Doctor and Robin take some time to get really stuck into a phenomenal comedic double act. It really was very entertaining.

Historically accurate

Interestingly it is Clara who gets to take the lead in coaxing out the Villain Monologue and securing a bit of back-story from the Sheriff. It's always good to see the Companion adding practical value rather than just being a warm body to explain things to or as an emotional foil for The Doctor.

The season arc tease was a little less offensive this episode in that Missy herself was blissfully absent, however it still seemed clumsily shoved in. We don't need the arc referenced in every episode. Let's just enjoy a standalone episode for once.

The Doctor works out the Sheriff's plan and why it won't work, revealing a flaw that will prove fatal to half the country. And here's where it all falls apart for me. Somehow, hitting the side of the ship with a golden arrow will give it a surge in lift and get it clear of the atmosphere. If the gold just needed to be in contact with the ship, why were they bothering to melt it down and forge those huge circuit board things? If a bit of extra gold on the outside would have got them clear, why didn't they use the stuff the peasants were escaping with, or the huge vat of Sheriff-infused gold that was still in the dungeon?

Hasta la vista, Sheriff.

Ignoring all of that, I liked that the three of them had to work together to pull it off, and the overall resolution of the episode was nice, especially Robin's words to The Doctor.

And today's team-building exercise is...

Overall, the episode ran a little short, making the whole thing seem a bit rushed. I can forgive The Doctor and Clara happening to materialise right next to Robin, thereby getting things moving quickly, but the Robin Hood legend is so rich that it's always going to be tough to get it into such a short space of time. We move straight from introducing characters to a major point in the legend. Add to this that (amusing as it was) a lot of time was chewed up on the banter between Robin and The Doctor and things just seem a little Go, go, go, Geronimo!

I have to say that I still found this episode to be great fun, and would totally re-watch. I have to give it extra points because my wife actually enjoyed this one, and she's not really a fan at all.

8/10

Can we fix it?

Just a couple of things to fix with this one, all related to the eventual solution. I think we needed a bit more explanation about how the Gold Matrix™ works, which could hopefully make me a bit more comfortable with how shooting a gold arrow into the side of the ship would result in a power surge.

I'm thinking that the Gold Matrix is installed on the exterior of the ship. We specifically see shots of the circuit-like panels as the castle crumbles away when the ship is taking off. The panels would appear to somehow feed energy into node points on the sides of the ship, which in turn power the engines.

The issue then is not that the ship cannot clear the atmosphere, but that it is unstable and will explode, but the robots aren't trying to clear the atmosphere, they are still following through with the Sheriff's plan of attacking London. They are doing this because the Sheriff is still in charge. Even without the beheading, seeing the Sheriff stumble into the control room covered in gold could be a good reveal that he is already mostly robot.

The Doctor would point all this out, indicating a direct infusion of gold into one of the node points would overload the matrix flight controls and cause the engine power to temporarily spike, sending the ship clear of the atmosphere. The rest of the scene would play out the same, only they would be much closer to the ship, because flinging a solid gold arrow that far taxes my suspension of disbelief no end.